Over 60 private unit owners in Camp John Hay are facing eviction following a decades-long legal battle between the Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA) and Camp John Hay Development Corporation (CJHDevCo). The unit owners, who claim to have purchased their properties in good faith, are appealing to President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. for intervention and are seeking clarification on their rights as property owners.
More than 60 private unit owners in Camp John Hay are facing eviction orders following a decades-long dispute over the former American military rest and recreation facility. Their January 27 letter to President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. highlights their urgent plea for assistance, citing their imminent displacement due to the enforcement of a writ of execution issued by the Baguio City Regional Trial Court, Branch 6, on January 7, 2025.
Notices to vacate have already been posted on their doors, and some unit owners claim they have been locked out of their properties.The conflict stems from a 1996 lease agreement between the Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA) and Camp John Hay Development Corporation (CJHDevCo), a private developer. CJHDevCo was awarded a 25-year lease to transform Camp John Hay into an eco-tourism and investment hub, with obligations to develop hotels, a golf course, commercial spaces, and residential units while paying lease rentals to BCDA. However, in the early 2000s, CJHDevCo ceased rental payments, arguing that BCDA failed to deliver promised tax incentives. The unpaid rent eventually ballooned to billions of pesos, triggering a lengthy legal battle. By 2012, BCDA terminated CJHDevCo’s lease due to non-payment, while CJHDevCo countered with lawsuits, leading to arbitration. In 2015, an arbitral tribunal ruled that both parties had breached their contract and issued the following directives: BCDA must refund CJHDevCo PHP 1.42 billion in rental payments. However, CJHDevCo refused to vacate and continued its operations within Camp John Hay, including its hotels, residential units, and golf course. The legal standoff persisted for nine more years as CJHDevCo fought eviction orders.In October 2024, the Supreme Court upheld the arbitral ruling, making it final and executory. By January 6, 2025, the Baguio sheriff enforced the order, issuing notices to vacate to CJHDevCo, its sub-lessees, and tenants. Unit owners insist that they purchased their properties in good faith, believing they had the legal right to occupy their homes until 2046. Many had invested their life savings into their properties, viewing them as retirement homes or income-generating rentals. “We acquired our units based on the understanding, with proper documentation, that we have rights to our properties until 2046,” the Camp John Hay Private Owners for Justice wrote in their letter to the President. “However, with the Supreme Court judgment now final and executory, we are being forced to vacate properties we purchased with our hard-earned money, leaving us feeling betrayed and helpless.” The unit owners also claim that they were never part of the legal battle between BCDA and CJHDevCo. “While the SC decision resolves the contractual disputes between these two entities, we, as third-party buyers, are unjustly caught in the crossfire,” they said. Unit owners are requesting the following: 1. To be allowed to remain in their units while they legally defend their rights as innocent purchasers who were not part of the BCDA-CJHDevCo arbitration. 2. BCDA engage in dialogue to find a resolution that recognizes their property investments while aligning with the government’s plans for Camp John Hay. While acknowledging BCDA’s plan to convert The Forest Lodge and The Manor into fully operational hotels, they argued that this can be done without disregarding their rights as homeowners.CJHDevCo’s stand: BCDA must honor private ownership In a statement on Thursday, February 6, CJHDevCo asserted that unit owners are not merely sub-lessees but legitimate property owners who built their homes in good faith during the period when BCDA was actively promoting public-private partnerships for Camp John Hay’s development. CJHDevCo maintains that BCDA cannot simply confiscate their properties based on the Supreme Court ruling, stating, “CJHDevCo was not directed by the Supreme Court to return Camp John Hay to BCDA free of its lawful occupants.” The statement also emphasized that the Supreme Court ruling did not mandate the turnover of privately owned improvements such as houses and condotel units. “CJHDevCo can only turn over improvements it still owns; not improvements now owned by its investors,” the company said
Camp John Hay BCDA Cjhdevco Eviction Land Dispute Supreme Court President Marcos Property Owners
Philippines Latest News, Philippines Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Camp John Hay Golf Course Reopens Under New Interim ManagementThe Camp John Hay Golf Club has reopened with new management, introducing updated terms and policies to maintain exclusivity while accommodating a wider range of players.
Read more »
Manny Pangilinan group lays out plans for The Manor, The Forest Lodge in Camp John HayAs the MVP Group takes the reins, their focus is on sustaining The Manor and The Forest Lodge as premier destinations while ensuring a smooth transition for employees, guests, and stakeholders
Read more »
Camp John Hay Golf Club members drop case against BCDAA class suit is withdrawn after the Bases Conversion Development Authority agrees to allow active members to maintain their playing privileges with a monthly fee of P5,000, eliminating additional green fees
Read more »
Camp John Hay Golf Course Operations Resume After BCDA TakeoverThe Camp John Hay Golf Course is back to normal operation following a two-day lockdown to facilitate the takeover by the Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA). The BCDA has taken control of the facility from Camp John Hay Development Corp. in line with a Supreme Court resolution.
Read more »
Supreme Court Ruling Hands Control of Camp John Hay to BCDAThe Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA) regains control over Camp John Hay in Baguio City, following a groundbreaking Supreme Court decision. This victory for the Filipino people paves the way for high-impact investments, job creation, and inclusive economic growth.
Read more »
BCDA eyes P10-b venture to redevelop Camp John HayState-run Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA) said it is laying the groundwork for a major redevelopment of Camp John Hay in Baguio City,
Read more »