The Supreme Court has established guidelines to ensure that confiscated firearms are presented correctly in court to prevent incorrect penalties or wrongful convictions. In the case of Togado vs. People, the Court emphasized the necessity of presenting the exact same firearm as evidence in specific instances.
The Supreme Court established guidelines in presenting confiscated firearms as evidence in court to prevent confusion that could lead to the imposition of incorrect penalties or conviction of an innocent person.
In the case of Togado vs. People penned by Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen, the SC En Banc acknowledged that it had stated previously that the actual firearm does not need to be presented as evidence.The Court said that where an accused is charged with violation of Comprehensive Firearms and Ammunition Regulation Act , the exact same confiscated firearm must be presented in court to determine whether the accused should be convicted and the proper penalty to be imposed.
Likewise, when the use of a firearm is a qualifying circumstance such as when it changes the nature of the crime, and the penalty imposable depends on the classification of the firearm, the exact same firearm must be presented in court. Meanwhile, in case when the use of a firearm is an aggravating circumstance such as when it increases the penalty to the maximum period imposable, or is inherent in or absorbed by the nature of the crime charged, the exact same firearm confiscated is only preferred, but the presentation of secondary evidence may also be considered.
The Court emphasized, however, that the confiscated firearm must be marked, photographed, and duly authenticated, and its integrity preserved in all situations where a firearm is confiscated from an accused.A mere certificate stating that the accused lacks a license to own or possess the firearm is not enough to secure a conviction, it added.
SUPREME COURT FIREARMS EVIDENCE LEGAL GUIDELINES WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS
Philippines Latest News, Philippines Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
SC leveraging AI to modernize court operationsThe Supreme Court (SC) announced that it will draft guidelines for the responsible integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) across various court
Read more »
DepEd issues guidelines for learning continuityMANILA, Philippines — The Department of Education (DepEd) on Monday issued guidelines to ensure the safety of learners and teachers, and guarantee learning continuity in the aftermath of Super Typhoon Pepito.
Read more »
Comelec to issue guidelines vs. red-tagging, gender-based sexual harassment for Eleksyon 2025Latest Philippine news from GMA News and 24 Oras. News, weather updates and livestreaming on Philippine politics, regions, showbiz, lifestyle, science and tech.
Read more »
DepEd issues safety guidelines for schoolsTHE Department of Education (DepEd) on Monday issued guidelines to ensure the safety of learners and teachers as well as learning continuity in the aftermath of Super Typhoon Pepito.
Read more »
New guidelines for preventing strokeSunStar Publishing Inc.
Read more »
DBM OKs guidelines for gov't procurement e-market pilotLatest Philippine news from GMA News and 24 Oras. News, weather updates and livestreaming on Philippine politics, regions, showbiz, lifestyle, science and tech.
Read more »