The first arbitral case concerning an opposed Philippine land took place long before the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) decided on July 12, 2016, in favor of the Philippines in the United Nat…
lawyer, as the sole arbitrator. This is ‘one of the most influential precedents dealing with island territorial conflicts.’
The Philippine view was premised on the geographic contiguity of the island to the Philippines; the discovery by Spain; and its inclusion in the 1989 Treaty of Paris. Netherlands, on the other hand, invoked its claim of the landmass by the continuous and peaceful display of sovereignty based on pacts signed as early as 1677 with the ruling princes of adjacent regions.
The arbitral court said the U.S. stance of contiguity and discovery was not proved and if Spain had a title to show, it is still under contest. The Netherlands, meanwhile, held that its possession and exercise of sovereignty of the atoll is an extension of the accords the East India Company, a Dutch company, signed with the indigenous ruler to even out the Dutch rule over the territory.
The arbitrator also pointed out that if there were discordant claims between the Dutch and the Spaniards, there would have been conflict, adding that an actual title, even if existent, cannot supplant the sovereignty exercised by the Dutch over the island ‘from 1677 or even prior to 1648,’ a territorial claim that was not challenged.
Philippines Latest News, Philippines Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
They’re coming back: SEVENTEEN announces additional show for ‘Be The Sun’ PHNot even a week after their back-to-back sold out shows in Manila, K-pop boy group SEVENTEEN confirms they’re going back to the Philippines! Full story:
Read more »
Neneng further intensifies while moving towards Babuyan Islands, BatanesTropical Storm Neneng has further intensified while moving westward towards the Babuyan Islands-Batanes area, PAGASA said on Saturday night.
Read more »
CE2 Roof Kote gets 2nd win in hoops tournament of architects, engineersCEBU CITY, Philippines — Civil Engineers-2 Roof Kote (CE2) grabbed their second straight win in the ongoing Architects and Engineers Basketball Club (AEBC): Island Premium Paints Cup on
Read more »
Neneng makes landfall in Cagayan after intensifying into severe tropical stormWeatherAlert: Severe Tropical Storm Neneng (Nesat) makes landfall in Calayan Island, Cagayan, at 3:50 am on Sunday, October 16. NenengPH
Read more »
Cebu Province temporarily bans entry of poultry from Iloilo and Panay IslandsCEBU CITY, Philippines -- Following reports of suspected African Swine Fever (ASF) cases in Iloilo and Panay Island, Cebu Gov. Gwendolyn Garcia banned the importation of live hogs, boar semen,
Read more »